An Education and History Boys Comparative Film Essay Essay

Through the analysis of where an instruction originates. The History Boys and An Education have two immensely contradictory point of views. The History Boys demonstrates both academic instruction and an instruction on life gained within school evidences. An Education. nevertheless. illustrates a immature Jenny Mellor ( Carey Mulligan ) as she additions her instruction far from her school environment – despite much attempted intercession.

In both The History Boys and An Education the instructors play an built-in function in determining the educational way for our supporters. Hector ( Richard Griffiths ) bases his instructions on the rule of educating the male childs in respect to life and non strictly academic acquisition. When the viewing audiences are foremost introduced to Hector. they are made cognizant of the high respect with which the male childs view him. During the scene when the male childs celebrate their concluding Markss. they bow down to Hector as if they are non worthy. If the mode in which Hector teaches the male child is considered. it becomes apparent that he understands the thought of literature possibly holding an impact on his pupils later in life – “all cognition is cherished whether or non it serves the slightest human purpose” .

This text is NOT unique.

Don't plagiarize, get content from our essay writers!
Order now

He seems to be concerned with how the male childs utilise their acquisition within mundane life ; how they apply thoughts and doctrines concealed in cognition at a standard worthy of Oxford and Cambridge. Within Hector’s schoolroom. there are many literary mentions present on the walls – more than one time the viewer’s eyes are drawn to a exposure of W H Auden – who can be considered similar to Hector in that both had homosexual dispositions. During the boys’ outing to an old monastery. Hector advises the male childs on cognition. and the transportation thereof. with the words. “pass it on” . In this. he is able to learn the male childs a lesson more of import than any taught in the schoolroom.

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!

order now

In An Education. Miss Stubbs every bit good as the Headmistress ( Emma Thompson ) allude to an instruction coming from within a school and being strictly academically centred. The Headmistress reminds Jenny that neither herself nor Miss Stubbs would be where they are if it were non for their nice school and university instruction. Miss Stubbs admits to Jenny that she attended Cambridge – merely to be offended by Jenny. who could no longer see the benefit of an academic instruction. Within Miss Stubbs’s schoolroom. we are able to see that the walls are reasonably empty and her desk unlittered. This stands in contrast with the Hector’s vibrant schoolroom.

In the opening scene of An Education the camera tracks the motion of the sheathings into Miss Stubbs’s schoolroom and to a group of misss who look stricken with ennui and subsequently on read with that same unenthusiastic demeanor. Continually throughout the film. we are reminded of the popular 1960s belief that instruction meant about everything if one was to go to a esteemed university and happen a occupation that provided a salary. but that was non needfully carry throughing.

The History Boys proves to the viewing audiences that life lessons can be and are taught within school parametric quantities. Although much of the focal point is centred on the Ox-Bridge scrutinies. Hector and Irwin. specifically. are able to learn the boys life lessons over and above the course of study. Hector teaches the male childs the importance of cognition. even if it has no obvious usage. To Hector. linguistic communication. literature and music are to be considered in high respect with the purpose of making a civilized being instead than one merely able to regurgitate useless ‘gobbets’ . as referred to by Irwin. The inquiry. “how does History go on? ” is asked more than one time throughout the film’s continuance.

As the movie progresses. the reply emerges – history is simply one thing after another. When the male childs are confronted with Hector’s decease. they are able to gain how fugitive life is. Death calls for self-contemplation and a deeper consideration of what it is in life that is genuinely of import. Hector is able to learn the male childs that instruction is indispensable in whichever signifier and from whichever beginning it comes. which. every bit good as the thought that one must go through cognition along. is a most important facet to the movie.

In An Education. it is clear that Jenny receives her instruction outside of school parametric quantities – despite the expostulations posed by Miss Stubbs and the Headmistress. Although Jenny is a dedicated pupil. who in the beginning attempts to derive her instruction within school and from her instructors. she necessarily additions it from her relationship with David ( Peter Sarsgaard ) . During the opening scene. the pupils dancing with books on their caput entreaties to the formal environment they attended school in. David was able to demo Jenny the other side of this spectrum – he introduced her to art. music. vino and munificent eating houses. David travelled to Oxford and Paris with Jenny. where everything was tinted with a blue haze and made to look flawless.

He provided her with a life where she could talk Gallic and environ herself with art and civilization ; the life she had so longed for. However. when Jenny discovered that David was a married adult male. she was besides able to larn that a lifestyle such as the one David and his friends led frequently hid many secrets. He was a dishonorable adult male – and it taught Jenny that trust should non merely be given. but instead earned. When she visits Miss Stubbs. her words. “I feel old. but non so wise” prove that when one is immature. they can so easy be deceived by philistinism and the thought of love – a lesson no school would be able to learn.

Both The History Boys and An Education demonstrate how instruction has no set definition. It can be defined as learning fact. or as larning about life. Both besides prove to us that instruction does non hold to come from an educational institute and its employees. Life can sometimes turn out more educational than the schoolroom.

Related essay samples:

  1. Is Coeducation Better than Single Sex Education? Essay
  2. « The History Boys »
  3. Education Reform Essay
  4. High School Girls Essay
  5. Cyber education Essay
  6. Single Sex School Essay
  7. Education in Victorian Essay
  8. Elementary School and Middle School: The Differences and Similarities Essay
  9. Inclusion Good Or Bad For Students Education Essay
  10. Benefits of Educational Trip Essay
  11. Strong Group Differences Between Males And Females Education Essay
  12. If I Were President Essay
  13. Freedmen’s Bureau Essay
  14. Barney Vs Sesame Street Essay Research Paper
  15. Fremont High School Discussion Essay