Lessons Learnt From Metallgesellschaft Finance Essay

Sells long-dated oil forwards hedged by “ stacking and peal ” oil hereafters. Unable to run into border calls, Metallgesellschaft has to be rescued by a pool of Bankss after losing $ 1.6 billion.


Metallgesellschaft AG, or MG is German pudding stone, owned mostly by Daimler-Benz, Deutsche Bank AG, Kuwait Investment Authority, Dresdner Bank AG and Allianz. MG is traditional metal company has evolved into a supplier of hazard direction services. They in charge of refinement and selling crude oil merchandises in the US with MG Refining and Marketing Inc. ( MGRM ) . Began 1991, MGRM ‘s expanded venture into derived functions with hiring of Arthur Benson from Louis Dreyfus Energy. It was Benson ‘s scheme that finally contributed to massive cash-flow crisis that MG experienced.

This text is NOT unique.

Don't plagiarize, get content from our essay writers!
Order now

At monetary values fixed in 1992, MGRM sell certain sums of crude oil every month for up to 10 old ages. Since it guaranteed a monetary value over the current topographic point monetary value, these contracts had successful in the beginning. By September of 1993, MGRM had sold frontward contract amounting of 160 million barrels. These trades is alone because these contract contained an ‘option ‘ clause which enabled the counterparties to end the contract early if the front month New York Mercantile Exchange ( NYMEX ) hereafters contract was greater than the fixed monetary value at which MGRM was sell the oil merchandise. MGRM would be required to pay in hard currency one-half of the difference between the future monetary value and the fixed monetary value times the entire volume staying to be delivered on the contract if the purchaser exercised this option. It will pull the clients who in fiscal hurt or no longer needed oil.

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!

order now

Actually, MGRM provided their clients with a method that enabled them to extinguish the oil monetary value hazard since the crude oil market is an environment plagued with big fluctuation in monetary value. To pull off topographic point monetary value hazard, MGRM ‘s hedge scheme was to utilize the front-end month hereafters contracts on NYMEX. It used a ‘stack ‘ hedge scheme which is it placed the full hedge in short-dated bringing months instead than distributing over longer-dated bringing months, because the call options were tied to the front-month hereafters contract at the NYMEX. MGRM used to fudge leadless gasolene and figure 2 heating oil with hereafters contract. MGRM went to hanker in the hereafters and entered into OTC energy barter understanding to have natation and pay fixed energy monetary values.

However, the premise of economic systems of graduated table was mistaken. MGRM expect to fudge away the hazard of lifting oil monetary values. But, it was the diminution in the monetary value of oil lead to fiscal hurt. Another job was the timing of cash-flows required to keep the hedge. MGRM was non apathetic to the way of oil monetary value motions because they were engaged in an indirect hedge of their forward places. The tremendous losingss they incurred did non merely consequence from bare future places in which MGRM speculated that the monetary value oil would increase but it would besides of future and swap places were hedged of the average term fixed rate oil merchandises they had sold frontward. A hedge is supposed to reassign market hazard, non increase it since the hedge scenarios were as follow, if oil monetary values diminution, the hedge losingss money and the fixed rate place additions in value but if oil monetary values rise, the hedge additions offset the fixed rate places losingss.

Equally long as the topographic point monetary values for oil and gas remain comparatively stable or increase over the one-month keeping period of the stack hedge contracts and the market is in backwardation, so a net income is earned utilizing this scheme. However, if the topographic point monetary value beads significantly, so losingss will be incurred. In the event the topographic point monetary value beads to less than the hereafters monetary values, the market is said to be Contango. Entering a long-position stack hedge in a Contango market can bring forth a net income merely if a topographic point and hereafters monetary values diverge or if topographic point monetary values addition while the footing spread does non diminish by an equal sum as if the hereafters monetary values addition. The axial rotation over hazard that that the oil market might travel into contango should hold been factored into the monetary value of the call options within MGRM ‘s forward fixed rate contracts.

The wake

The Metallgesellschaft AG ( MG ) ‘s financial twelvemonth ended on Sept. 30, 1993, and it bit by bit became apparent that the parent company would hold to unwrap the extent of the US affiliate ‘s paper losingss emerging from its monolithic barters places. In early December 1993, imperativeness studies began to go around. Trading of MG ‘s stock was suspended in Frankfurt on Jan. 6, 1994. MG issued an proclamation to its stockholders in early January that losingss were “ about $ 1 billion. ” MGRM ‘s supervisory board had decided in December 1993 to stop the forward-sales plan and appointed a new direction squad to wind off its places.

The MG matter give three primary messages to petroleum industry, which are affecting the relationship between fudging and theorizing, corporate administration and trade good market kineticss. On the message of hedge and speculating, MG Refining and Marketing ( MGRM ) designed an advanced plan aimed at rapid enlargement in a mature but germinating business- the selling of crude oil merchandises. Sing the issue of corporate administration, the extent of MGRM ‘s activities in fiscal energy markets appears to hold caught its parent by surprise. On the facet of market kineticss, MGRM ‘s unfastened involvement in the oil fiscal markets, both exchange traded and over the counter became highly big.

In early 1994, MG AG ‘s direction terminated the MGRM plan. Since it is terminated, the matter inspired Christopher Culp and Merton H. Miller to print a valuable aggregation of analytical essays that concentrate about wholly on the issues of fudging versus guess and corporate administration. They defended MGRM, based on the position that the “ stack and axial rotation ” scheme could hold worked but it required really considerable funding on the portion of its parent company. Mello and Parsons jumped into the argument with a paper that defined the MG turn overing stack scheme as guess in the spring of 1995. The word picture of MGRM ‘s plan as hedge or guess becomes the major points of contention in the postmortems of the MGRM derivatives plan. In the summer of 1995, MG settled a ailment lodged against it by the Commodities Futures Trading Commission to get away admittance of guilt and brought to illume the basic narrative of the minutess whereby MG attempted to go a major participant in the US oil market.

Lessons learned

From this survey, we noted that Metallgesellschaft did non affect fraud. Rather, their stack and axial rotation hedge exposed them to footing hazard. They besides exist a displacement to Contango that created losingss on axial rotation return where the axial rotation return net incomes are on backwardation and the losingss are on Contango. Then, the accounting criterion required acknowledgment of hereafters losingss but non frontward additions.

From this, we can learned that the short-run hedge against long-run contacts require liquidness. The uncertainness of axial rotation returns was taking into consideration and besides we can larn that liquidness consideration may prefer other than minimal discrepancy hedge. The Stack-and axial rotation involves purchasing a stack ( bundle ) of short-run futures/forwards contract with the purpose of fudging a long- term exposure. Each chaff is “ rolled over ” merely before termination by selling bing contract while purchasing another stack of contracts for more distant bringing day of the month. Metallgesellschaft used short-dated contract because the hereafter markets for most trade goods have comparatively small liquidness beyond the first few contract day of the months. The additions or losingss on each side of the forward and hereafters minutess should hold offset each other.

The scheme was inefficient for two grounds. The first factor was the market shifted to Contango do the hereafters monetary value is greater than the topographic point monetary value. Then, the 2nd factor was German accounting methods required Metallgesellschaft to demo hereafters losingss ( i.e. , from hedge ) but could non acknowledge unfulfilled additions from the forward. These reported losingss triggered border calls and a terror, which led to recognition evaluation downgrades.

Related essay samples:

  1. Study On The Financial Strategies Used By Metallgesellschaft Finance Essay
  2. Types Of Risk An International Multinational Company Face Finance Essay
  3. Risk Management Of Financial Derivatives Finance Essay
  4. The trading objectives of hedgers, speculators and arbitrageurs.
  5. Tiffany: Futures Contract and Exchange-rate Risk Essay
  6. Julies bakeshop Essay
  7. Key Characteristics Of Hedge Funds Finance Essay
  8. Definition And Uses Of Short Selling Finance Essay
  9. Case Analysis Eastman Kodak Company Marketing Essay
  10. Marketing Mix Pricing Pricing Marketing Essay
  11. A Study On Inflation Rate Finance Essay
  12. Identifying The Hedging Of Foreign Currency In Infosys Finance Essay
  13. Allocation And The Fund Of Funds Model Finance Essay
  14. Dozier: Foreign Exchange Market and Forward Contract
  15. The role of an organisations treasury department